I wanted to bring to your attention an ongoing issue that we, as a community,
have been facing with creating backups on our instances.
We have been experiencing issues where backups are not working at all and, when they do, they break the integrity of internal files, causing a lot of downtime and frustration.
Furthermore, the scheduling system for backups seems to be malfunctioning, causing AMP to fail completely.
We have also been experiencing issues with updating the instance, sometimes resulting in errors.
It is clear that these issues are not unique to our server, as they have been reported multiple times on this forum by other users.
Also to make the issue more frustrating, the logs are complicity empty because AMP thinks that the backup was successful…
I have a suspicion that it may not be possible to backup a FiveM server while it’s running, it may be holding open file locks everywhere which makes it difficult to manage. In many ways it’s a very poorly put together server that is difficult to wrangle into something AMP can handle.
The PoweredBy tag is part of an agreement with the FiveM developers and will not be removed. Normally they do not allow automated tools to set up and manage FiveM servers but we were able to negotiate an exemption.
yep, The FiveM community is not the best to work with, the issue is that even if the server is offline and the backup doesn’t work.
honestly, the most important files to backup are the resources folders and CFG files, as most data is stored on the database
A solution to this issue would be to implement a backup system that allows users to select which CFG files to backup, up and also includes the resources folder.
also, this is currently an urgent matter as FiveM instances are not functioning due to changes made by the FiveM dev team.
It’s possible they may be trying to deliberately make it harder to allow automated updates. Frankly I’m close to dropping support for FiveM and advising people to switch over to AltV instead because of how hostile the FiveM guys are (despite the informal agreement I have with the devs)
They’ve moved to a new URL but didn’t document it. I’ve managed to figure out the new URL and have made the change to accommodate this. CI and Nightly will have a fix soon, mainline will update later this week.
FiveM is a popular community-maintained project, but it is primarily run by a group of 15-25 year-olds.
Despite its success, certain aspects of the project have been neglected and the welcoming, open-source community atmosphere has dissipated.
The maintainers have been known to arbitrarily close pull requests, and there is no security or contribution policy in place.
Additionally, they charge excessively for simple player synchronization features (One Sync).
Despite these issues, it is important to continue supporting the AMP FiveM Instance, as it may be Very difficult to find an alternative.
It should be supported until it is no longer feasible, whether that be through the closure of cfx.re or drastic changes to the update and API processes.
we (you) cloud open-source the AMP instance for FiveM, and if changes like this one arise again we as a community can maintain it
The agreement I have with the FiveM devs to allow AMP to deploy it automatically doesn’t allow for the module to be open sourced, as that would allow someone to bypass the check that prevents it from running under Enterprise installations. The agreement is only possible because I have decent control over who can and can’t use the FiveM module.
So if it becomes unmaintainable there may be very few options, short of disabling the ability to perform automatic updates, requiring that the user provide the files.